Can Blues strike gold with domestic loans?

Jul 17th, 2010 | By KevB8ll | Category: Articles by Nicole Carroll, Blues News, Players

This is Nicole’s latest blog. Originally published here. We re-publish with full permission.

With clubs like Portsmouth feeling the financial strain of over spending, Premier League clubs will be keen to avoid huge transfer fees by taking advantage of the loan scheme.

Within the Premier League you can loan 2 players off a fellow club (but no two players from the same club). Last season Blues plumped for Manchester City’s Joe Hart which was arguably the Premier League loan of the season, and Sunderland’s Teemu Tainio who unfortunately sustained an injury which cut his season short.

Blues are very light in cover across all areas of the pitch, and we would be kidding ourselves as fans if we really believed that management could afford to buy players to cover all the areas we need. To ensure we have players to be able to last the season, allowing for injuries and fatigue, we’re looking at needing at least one centre half, a left back, a winger and a striker.

If McLeish could emerge from this window with two very decent loan signings in tow, it could go a long way to ensuring Premier League survival for a second season. Joe Hart was instrumental to this last season, but now we have Ben Foster as a permanent signing, we can somewhat relax and focus on strengthening the outfield areas.

Realistically, we’re looking at the teams above us loaning us an outstanding youngster, or perhaps players who have become surplus to requirement at the moment due to new players arriving at their clubs.

Perhaps, however, we could go knocking on Manchester City’s door again in the hope of taking defender Nedum Onuoha on loan. Despite playing semi regularly in 2008-2009, injuries and new arrivals to the club have now seen the young defenders chances limited. His team mate Joe Hart had only positive things to say about the club, perhaps if Blues knocked at the door he could be persuaded to visit the Midlands for 9 months. The fact he is versatile and can play in the centre and at right back would mean we had options at the back, especially if we are going to face injury problems this season.

An option to add to midfield and cover the left hand side of the pitch could be Portsmouth’s loan signing last season, Jamie O’Hara. He received good reviews for his season on the coast, and perhaps if he isn’t to focus in Harry Redknapp’s plans this season, then he could move to the Midlands to get regular football. If O’Hara wasn’t an option, then why not Danny Rose, the scorer of THAT screamer against Arsenal last season. Despite him getting on the score sheet, that was the only league appearance he made last season. Although he’s relatively unknown except for that goal, he must have something about him to be signed for the Spurs first team, perhaps a season at somewhere like Blues could really show what this young player is made of?

Can we loan someone with the talent of Mikael Forssell? I’m not sure that a striker will be coming to Blues on loan from a fellow Premier League club. Blues struck lucky when they loaned Mikael Forssell from Chelsea and he went on to be a complete hit at St. Andrews. Blues dipped their toes into loaning a foreign striker in the shape of Christian Benitez, who struggled to set the league alight. It’s difficult to judge whether a player will translate their own domestic form into the Premier league, and even if they are outstanding, you run the risk that someone bigger is going to come along and buy them from under your nose.

Maybe this would be where, if McLeish was going to explore the options here, he would possibly talk to fellow manager Sir Alex Ferguson and perhaps see whether United had a young striker who was ready for first team Premier League experience. Signing someone on loan until January maybe could prove enough time to see whether a gamble could pay off. Loan moves like these when they work well are massively beneficial to all three parties, and if it works out well there is always a possibility that you could get the player permanently.

Whilst Blues are currently on tour in Asia, it seems highly unlikely that any new faces or much business will be conducted at all. By the time the players are back at Wast Hills, perhaps McLeish and his backroom staff will have identified some possible loan moves for Premier League players that they can slot into the squad for the start of the season. With teams like Manchester City spending in a big way, there perhaps will be talent that other clubs like Blues can take full advantage of to bolster the squad without any hard commitment.

Nicole C

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

5 Comments to “Can Blues strike gold with domestic loans?”

  1. Peter says:

    Danny Rose is 20 years old and has played more games for his country at U17, U19 and U21 level than he has for Leeds, Tottenham, Watford and Peterborough put together. I’ve no idea how good he is but surely he is an example of what’s wrong with English football.
    Forget about abolishing FA Cup replays and mid winter breaks, just give young players the opportunity to develop and prove how good they are.

  2. Bluenose 'John' says:

    Sorry but for the second time in a week I find myself disagreeing. I think it’s rather pessimistic to think that without two decent loan signings we are not going to be able to survive. Which is what you seem to be suggesting. Last season we coped with virtually one. This side is better equipped than last year and I believe that is an example for not needing a loan signing at all. If we do bring in a loan player then it would be to strengthen a position and wouldn’t be a first choice. The two players that you’ve mentioned; Danny Rose and Jamie O’Hara (both at Spurs) would not be realistic. As Spurs plan to offload O’Hara and don’t wish to loan him out again. I think that they have also categorically stated this. As for Rose I’d imagine Spurs wouldn’t want to loan him to Blues. Who they could still see as a possible threat and I’d imagine that’s the same with Man City regarding Onuha. We only finished 5 or 4 places below them last year!!

    :) Bluenose ‘John’.

  3. Nicole says:

    Thats not what I’m talking about at all.

    1. We’re nowhere near the level of Man City or Spurs. We had a fantastic season last year where we got 100% from the team and were incredibly lucky with injuries. One season in the Premier League does not confirm you as a top ten team, look at Hull, finished in the top half one season, relegated the next. We are more at the level of Blackburn or Fulham, no where near the levels of Man City or Spurs which is why we could realistically knock on the door for players. We are of no immediate threat to Manchester City who will challenge for the title next season

    2. The squad is thin, and its unrealistic to suggest we can outright buy players we need in the weak positions. 2 Premier League loans at least bulk out the side and add a greater depth of quality. We won’t be able to guarantee staying up with these additional players, no, but if we hit a torrid patch of injuries, we could be left rueing not bringing extras into the squad.

    Surely, looking at loaning some of the leagues best young talent is a massively positive step for the club? I don’t think I was negative once throughout. To think that the squad we have now is equal to those in the upper echelons of the league just isn’t something you can say right at the moment. If we bring no more players into the club by the end of the window (which is doubtful), the only way we’ll see if our squad is good enough is by our position at Christmas.

  4. TarantiniDust says:

    I think Eck would be foolish not to utilise the loan system and I don’t think he is a fool. We obviously need a left winger, striker, centre half and left back.

    We have been linked with several purchases at left wing, striker and a couple at left back so it would seem likely that he is holding his loan options for centre half (we only have 3) and right wing (we have no real cover for Seb although centre midfield Gardiner can cover if necessary).

    Trouble is have the teams below us got surplus quality we can exploit and will youngsters from a higher club get the game time they are looking for by coming to us?

    Eck hasn’t been slow to utilise foreign loans (Benitez, Costly spring to mind) so I wouldn’t be surprised to see a “left field” foreign loan as well.

  5. I_Don't_Know_Any_Other_Way_To_Lead_But_By_Example says:

    We will not be loaned players by Man City or Spurs. If there players that could be a first choice for us then they would be without doubt a second choice for them! You would be naive to think otherwise. The squad is good enough to finish at least 15th in the PL as it is. The vast majority of Bluenoses that I’ve spoken to agree we’ll be able to stay up as we are, remember we finished 9th last year!!

Leave a Comment